Paying cash and negotiating price: Will it reduce the cost of health care and coverage?

Many of us now have high-deductible health insurance plans, which makes us “cash-pay” patients until we meet our deductibles. According to a Health Affairs health policy brief, high deductible plans are now much more prevalent in both individual and group markets.The higher the deductible, the lower the monthly premium. If you have a high deductible plan and don’t consume much medical care, you are most likely a cash pay patient. You might even avoid medical care because of the out of pocket cost. I know I have.I talked with a friend yesterday who has a $9,000 deductible. She has a torn meniscus. She is avoiding the surgery because she isn’t even close to hitting her plan’s deductible. I suggested she try asking for a “cash pay” price from her surgeon and the hospital or surgery center where her procedure would be performed. Negotiating cash pay prices for medical treatment has become a common practice. Often a cash-pay price for medical care can be much less than what you’d have to pay if you haven’t met your deductible.

Source: How cash-pay patients can beat high-deductible plans

The strategy of paying cash for medical care to get a better price originally appeared in The Los Angeles Times and is getting legs elsewhere such as here. That’s the way it was back in the 1950s and 1960s where people had “major medical” insurance that covered only large and unexpected medical care needs such as auto accidents and heart attacks. Everything else was paid on a cash basis.

Going forward, it bears watching to see if this gains momentum among those covered by high deductible plans. If it does, it could create downward pricing pressure on non-emergency medical procedures including primary care visits that aren’t preventative care and thus subject to out of pocket cost sharing.

Ditto high deductible plan rates. If more people pay providers directly rather than engaging in the paperwork exercise with their health plans for care falling well below their annual deductible, that reduces the administrative burden on the issuers of high deductible plans. As well as providers willing to negotiate a cash price knowing they’ll get paid sooner with less paperwork.

There’s an added bonus for high deductible plan members. At one time, having a high deductible plan meant a broader choice of providers. No longer the case with today’s narrow networks. Paying cash can potentially substantially widen the provider network to any provider willing to accept cash as payment in full for services.


Need a speaker or webinar presenter on the Affordable Care Act and the outlook for health care reform? Contact Pilot Healthcare Strategies Principal Fred Pilot by email or call 530-295-1473. 

About Author

Frederick Pilot

%d bloggers like this: